Juan Brignardello Vela
Juan Brignardello, asesor de seguros, se especializa en brindar asesoramiento y gestión comercial en el ámbito de seguros y reclamaciones por siniestros para destacadas empresas en el mercado peruano e internacional.
The recent leak of communications between Judge Alexandre de Moraes and his advisors has shed light on an alarming phenomenon: the transformation of the Judiciary into an entity of censorship. What was once considered a bastion of freedom of expression now presents itself as an instrument of repression. This shift not only raises serious questions about the independence of the judicial system but also threatens the very foundations of the Democratic Rule of Law. The recordings reveal explicit requests to "adjust" reports and find "evidence" to justify punitive actions against journalists and media outlets. This type of control over information, which seeks to silence dissenting voices, is a flagrant violation of constitutional guarantees. The Brazilian Constitution clearly establishes in its Article 5 the right to freedom of expression and prohibits any form of political or ideological censorship in Article 220. However, reality seems to indicate that these precepts are fading under the pressure of an increasingly authoritarian state. The case of Minister Dias Toffoli in 2019, who felt aggrieved by an article linking him to the Lava Jato scandal, is a paradigmatic example of how the line between legitimate criticism and judicial persecution has become blurred. The decision to censor the magazine Crusoé and establish the inquiry into fake news marks a turning point. This inquiry, far from being a tool of justice, has served as a mechanism to concentrate power in the Supreme Court and undermine the foundations of democracy. This use of the judiciary as a tool of censorship has created an environment in which arbitrary detentions and disproportionate fines are commonplace. The figure of Minister de Moraes has evolved from being a judge to becoming an unrelenting persecutor of those who criticize or oppose the current regime. This process not only affects individuals but has also led to a growing climate of self-censorship in media outlets and social platforms. As this repression intensifies, it is crucial to point out that the erosion of democracy is not only the result of abuse of power by the authorities. The complicity of society is equally alarming. The normalization of intolerance and polarization has allowed actions that would have been considered unacceptable in the past to be justified. The idea that fundamental freedoms must be sacrificed to protect democracy is a fallacy that has found resonance in various sectors. In this strained atmosphere, some voices argue that censorship is a necessary means of protecting order. However, this dystopian narrative is dangerously misguided. Protecting democracy should never involve restricting fundamental rights. History has shown that regimes that begin justifying repression in the name of security or stability often end in authoritarianism. The responsibility to defend freedom and democracy rests on all of us. It is imperative that citizens, media, and educational institutions unite in the defense of a plurality of ideas. The press must return to its essential role as a beacon of truth, without allowing partisan or ideological interests to taint it. Classrooms should be spaces for debate and critical thinking, where a diversity of opinions is encouraged rather than dogmatic conformity. If censorship is allowed to become a normal aspect of our daily lives, we risk raising a generation that accepts repression and state control without question. This path, if not halted, will lead to the decomposition of democratic values and an irreparable loss of freedom. The struggle for democracy is a constant and collective commitment. We cannot allow fear and intolerance to prevail. It is time for everyone, from citizens to opinion leaders, to raise their voices and defend the right to express themselves freely, without fear of reprisals. Democracy, ultimately, is built day by day, and each of us has a crucial role in its defense.